| Team Name - Overall Team of the Year | Head Cook Name |
| • 2021 – Gettin’ Basted | Brad Leighninger |
| • 2020 – Gettin’ Basted | Brad Leighninger |
| • 2019 – Boomerang BBQ | Matt Walker |
| • 2018 – Gettin’ Basted | Brad Leighninger |
| • 2017 – Clark Crew BBQ | Travis Clark |
| • 2016 – Porky Butts BBQ | Blane Hunter |
| • 2015 – Clark Crew BBQ | Travis Clark |
| • 2014 – Warren County Pork Choppers | Donny Bray |
| • 2013 – Truebud BBQ | Tim Grant |
| • 2012 – 3 Eyz BBQ | Dan Hixon |
| • 2011 – Munchin Hogs At The Hilton | Rob Magee |
| • 2010 – Quau | Mike Wozniak |
| • 2009 – Pellet Envy | Rod Grey |
| • 2008 – Munchin Hogs At The Hilton | Rob Magee |
| • 2007 – Cool Smoke | Tuffy Stone |
| • 2006 – Lotta Bull BBQ | Mike Davis |
| • 2005 – Twin Oak Smokin Crew | Dick Clarke |
| • 2004 – Twin Oak Smokin Crew | Dick Clarke |
| • 2003 – Smokin’ Triggers | Johnny Trigg |
| • 2002 – Pdt | |
| • 2001 – Smokin’ In The Boys Room | |
| • 2000 – Smokin’ In The Boys Room | |
| • 1999 – Smokin’ In The Boys Room | |
| • 1998 – Smokin’ In The Boys Room | |
| • 1997 – Armadillo Bob’s Bar-B-Q | |
| • 1996 - Happy Holla BBQ | Ed Roith |
| • 1995 – Happy Holla BBQ | Ed Roith |
| • 1994 – Happy Holla BBQ | Ed Roith |